Se habla español

Legal Consultation Over the Desk

I recently attended a riveting lecture by Northwestern Law’s Constitutional Law Professor Paul Gowder, an entertaining and engaging speaker with a special interest in Classical Athenian law and democracy.1

Professor Gowder’s lecture was on birthright citizenship in the context of the 14th Amendment, with a provocative thesis: birthright citizenship as a floor, not a ceiling. Why not also grant citizenship to someone who earns a doctorate here, or serves in the military? What makes someone “worthy” of citizenship?

Quick answer: who is an heir in Illinois? If someone dies without a will or trust, the Illinois Probate Act decides who inherits, starting with a spouse and children and moving outward to more distant relatives.2 Stepchildren and unmarried partners are not heirs unless a will or trust names them. A funded trust keeps that question out of court.

What does citizenship have to do with probate?

Well, to give context for his thesis, Professor Gowder covered the history of citizenship, from Ancient Greece to today, to contextualize our modern approach to citizenship and the resulting immigration policies. In doing so, he introduced the historical case study of Neaira (also spelled Neaera) in ancient Greece, which centered around Ancient Greece’s ties between citizenship and inheritance.

It turns out that in Ancient Greece, your citizenship determined whether you could inherit from your parents. If your father was a citizen but your mother wasn’t, you weren’t “citizen enough” to inherit from him!

As an unabashed probate nerd, I had Neaira’s case pulled up on my phone in the Uber home from the lecture. Indeed it reads like a contested probate proceeding: the whole fight is over who is legitimate, who is family, and who gets to inherit.

The Trial of Neaira

I take you back to Ancient Greece…

Around 340 BC, Apollodorus, a prosecutor, hauled a woman named Neaira into an Athenian court on the charge that she, a foreigner, had been living as the wife of an Athenian citizen, Stephanus, and passing her children off as citizens.3

According to Apollodorus, Neaira, who had begun life as a slave in a brothel outside of Athens and given birth to a daughter, Phano, eventually landed in Athens and lived with Stephanus as his wife. Phano was then married off as though she were Stephanus’s legitimate Athenian daughter.

In Athens, your parents’ Athenian citizenship determined whether you could inherit. A child needed to be the legitimate child of an Athenian father and an Athenian mother to inherit property. A foreign-born mother meant no citizenship and no inheritance.

Phano married Phrastor, and they had a son. But when Phrastor found out that Phano’s mother Neaira was actually a Corinthian courtesan masquerading as an Athenian, he threw Phano out. Wanting his son to inherit, rather than his other family, he took his son in and held him out as his heir. Of course the members of his clan, learning that Neaira wasn’t a true citizen, and so neither were Phano or her son, refused to accept the child as his legitimate heir.

Apollodorus hated Stephanus, so he had no problem dragging Neaira to court to spite him and make an example of Neaira. He used Phrastor’s story as evidence: members of Phrastor’s own clan, who had no part in the feud, had already refused to treat Neaira’s grandson as one of their own. Apollodorus took that as proof that Phano was never a citizen’s legitimate daughter.

Who Is an Heir in Illinois Today?

“Who counts” is still the first question in probate. I’ve handled almost 2000 probate estates, and the question in every one of them is the same one Apollodorus was asking in 340 BC: who is an heir?

Luckily, today’s laws don’t require citizenship for heirship, but who is an heir is still defined by law. When someone dies without a plan in Illinois, the Probate Act determines who inherits and who doesn’t.4 A stepchild you raised from age four is not an heir. A child born outside of marriage can be, but the father’s side has to be established. A child who has been estranged for 20 years is every bit as much an heir as the child who lived with and took care of the deceased for those same 20 years.

PersonHeir with no will or trust?
Stepchild you raised from age fourNo
Child born outside of marriageYes, if the father’s side is established
Child estranged for 20 yearsYes
Unmarried partnerNo

Inheritance notwithstanding, citizenship still matters in modern estate work. A U.S. citizen can leave a spouse everything free of federal estate tax. If that spouse isn’t a U.S. citizen, the rules change, and a plan needs a Qualified Domestic Trust (QDOT) to keep the benefit.5

Apollodorus made his case in a public Athenian courtroom. That’s what an unplanned probate looks like: an open door for heirship questions, creditors, public records, and relatives with opinions. A properly funded trust keeps all of that private. With a plan in place, nobody in your family has to go to court to prove that they count.

What To Do Next

If you’ve got a blended family, a child from a prior relationship, a spouse who isn’t a citizen, or just a will you wrote years ago and a vague feeling it isn’t enough, book a free 15-minute phone consultation with my team. No pressure, no pitch. If you want a full plan, the next step is a $500 design meeting, credited toward your plan. Flat fee, four-week turnaround. Learn more about our estate planning and probate administration services, and how a funded trust avoids probate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is an heir in Illinois?

When someone dies without a plan, the Illinois Probate Act determines who inherits and who doesn’t.

Is a stepchild an heir in Illinois?

No. A stepchild you raised from age four is not an heir unless the child was legally adopted or a will or trust names them.

Can a child born outside of marriage inherit in Illinois?

Yes, but the father’s side has to be established.

Does an estranged child still inherit in Illinois?

Yes. A child who has been estranged for 20 years is every bit as much an heir as the child who lived with and took care of the deceased for those same 20 years.

Do you need to be a U.S. citizen to be an heir in Illinois?

No. Citizenship does matter for estate tax. A U.S. citizen can leave a spouse everything free of federal estate tax, but if the spouse isn’t a U.S. citizen, the plan needs a Qualified Domestic Trust (QDOT) to keep that benefit. See our post on marital rights for more.

This post is general information, not legal advice.

References

    1. https://gowder.io/
    2. Illinois Probate Act of 1975, 755 ILCS 5/2-1 (descent and distribution).
    3. Against Neaera (Oration 59).
    4. Illinois Probate Act of 1975, 755 ILCS 5/2-1 (descent and distribution).
    5. 26 U.S.C. § 2056A (qualified domestic trusts)

    Get the Latest Updates

    By completing this form, you agree to receive automated SMS messages, emails, and voicemails from Bielski Chapman, Ltd. Your information will not be shared, and you may opt-out at any time.

    A Plan Brings Peace of Mind

    The top concern we hear from clients is simple. What happens if I do not have a plan?

    Without proper planning, estates can fall into probate litigation that costs between five thousand and one hundred thousand dollars in legal fees and family conflict.

    With proper planning, families gain clarity, tax efficiency, and peace of mind.

    If you want to protect your family, your business, and your legacy, we are here to guide you.

    Schedule your consultation with Bielski Chapman, Ltd. today.